HP: The Arcane Thief

I really liked this story. Its MC is clever and a bit OP. Yes, it’s a Harry Potter Fanfic, but it has its own very unique background that is completely different than the original. It sort of like it’s in an alternate universe of Harry Potter. I won’t say anything about comparing the two as I believe it has branched off from the original quite cleanly. I do like the romance in this story. It’s quirky and I believe it’ll get better. It looks like it might be a harem, but so far the MC has only opened up to 1 of 3 potential romances. He only considers the other 2 friends… which is A LOT considering his loner/independent attitude. Cons — I didn’t like how everything seemed to practically revolve around the MC. The writer seems to play it off as the MC faces even more terrible challenges, hence why the MC is always getting stronger quickly… but the MC is still considered a pre-teen/teenager. I didn’t like how every woman character with at least some importance seems to fall for the MC or care for him… even if they’re an adult already.

Started out pretty good, however it fell off pretty fast. The book overall is filled with red pill content and vulgural language (I don't mind but it just became funny when author started writing "He went to a f*ck*ng zoo" rather than "He went to a zoo" when explaining mc's actions). Basically there is zero realism in this fanfic's characters - Children being too mature for their age, their actions sometimes are too forced, MC has a "peak male physique" before even hitting puberty and author sometimes even adds sexual subtexts. It feels sometimes like author is a teen which is possible considering he keeps using words such as "sigma", "rizz" or "top g". MC is edgy and dense in terms of relationships but he's not stupid. His powers and abilities are nice and he could be considered "overpowered". World and plot really differs from the original HP storyline and author changed almost everything in a pretty nice way which doesnt make it too absurd (He adds alot of new good content). Novel's pace is pretty slow and inconsistent. Honestly I think author had a pretty nice idea for the beginning of the novel, I certainly liked the concept behind MC being a thief in HP world and his traumatic past only added to the immersion. However after 80 chapters the book is filled with romance, dramas and misunderstandings. I honestly can't recall when was the last time he actually stole something considering he's an "arcane thief". I don't really recommend this novel unless you have nothing else to read or are really into HP fanfics. 6/10

I still don't understand why this is so low in the ranking, usly, it's stupid, but hey, let's start. It is a fanfiction book about the world of Harry Potter with a part of isekai and system. Although the isekai is not on the part of the protagonist, the protagonist is originally from the world of Harry Potter, it has a solid story, what I like most is the character development, it is wonderful, you really feel the character of the main characters grow. The world development is good as it is the world of harry potter, but the author takes clever routes and only uses the world of harry potter as a help, that is, he does not use the arcs of the original book, he creates his own arcs, which It is very detailed and fresh. So don't expect to see the world of Harry Potter like in the original books or movies, even the characters in the saga are not the same, they are a kind of different version, Harry Potter Potter is a woman for example. I simply recommend reading the book, it is not boring and its fights and occasions outside of them are entertaining and you will never get bored. Story 3. 8/5, characters 5/5, world 4/5, and writing 4/5. Recommended

My second favorite novel on this site. Has a system element and is a perfect fan fiction of Harry Potter. The author implements their own MC and creates a rather unique twist to the wizarding world. The author implements other magic communities outside such as Atlantis and Ninjitsu. A good book that is not updated as much as it should.

Haven't read many HP fanfics, but this is definitely the best, the concept of the world is different from the original and makes it much more interesting, there's also a presence of ninjutsu which is pretty nice. The only problem with this novel is that the mc is too young to have experienced so many violent and traumatizing things, it would have been better for the mc to be older to make it more believable, but I see how it can be hard to implement because you go Hogwarts at 11

This is definitely by far the best Harry Potter fanfic I've read. The mc is written well and is a good character. There is loads of funny and great scenes that make the novel great. There a few problems though, the first being the chapter length is terribly short, there are a few cringe moments(especially when they start calling axel savage) and in my opinion axel gets insanely strong way too quick other than that the novel is great and deserves a read.

Honestly think this should be ranked higher. Really good novel and I love the MC as a character. Only "downsides" I can think of is they're so little chapters and the release rate kinda sucks especially after the hiatus.

Happy Potter and a system novel. . . such a great mix. He also isn't to over powered initially and has to work for his power. Also love how it gets into to dark parts of the magical world of Harry Potter.

One of the best fan ficts iv read in a while great world building alot of diffrent cultures put into an already existing universe the mc isn't a typical beta male he's pretty strong but not too op some edgy moments but not too bad it's overall a good read

There are a lot of changes(good) to make the world more understandable and i really like them the world doesn't revolve around only Hogwarts but other communities are also shown like Japanese magic and we might see more the mc is edgy but he is getting his character development.